Most of Wall Street’s biggest commercial real estate lenders are getting paid back faster than they’re lending, and their dividends are starting to crack.
The public lenders are losing ground just as private credit fights hardest for deals, pushing spreads on top-quality loans tighter even after the Federal Reserve’s September rate hike, Bisnow reported last week.
The mortgage REITs piled into lending when rates were near zero, and losses on those 2021 and 2022 loans are now eating the capital they would need to compete. Analysts who spoke with Bisnow don’t expect them back in force until the middle of next year at the earliest.
Blackstone Mortgage Trust cut its quarterly dividend 36% to 30 cents a share after a $327M third-quarter loss, the company reported late last month, and collected $2.3B in repayments while closing about $500M in new investments. KKR Real Estate Finance Trust got $1.2B back from borrowers and made just $157M in new loans, according to its earnings release, and its book value has fallen 26% in a year to $10.14 a share.
)
Even Starwood Property Trust, which made $2.4B in commercial loans in the quarter, its most in four years, posted a $390M loss, the company reported Nov. 6, and is weighing a cut to the 48-cent dividend it has paid for more than a decade.
“It’s all blue sky for them,” BTIG Managing Director Thomas Catherwood told Bisnow of the private lenders. “Whereas the public guys are still dealing with this overhang.”
Starwood CEO Barry Sternlicht said on the company’s earnings call that the dividend has been running above earnings and that the board will meet to set a new rate.
“It hurts me to do anything to the dividend,” Sternlicht said. “But I think the right thing to do is navigate through this valley.”
KREF has gone further, running a strategic review that could end in a sale or merger.
Those legacy loans tie the REITs’ hands in a way they don’t for private funds, said Kim Golden, director of nonbank financial institutions at Fitch Ratings. REITs must pay out at least 90% of their taxable income to shareholders, so they can't rebuild capital by holding on to earnings, and impaired legacy loans are eating into the equity that supports their borrowing.
“The REITs themselves are not able to [invest] while staying in their leverage levels as they kind of work through some of these impaired loans, which were originated in pre-2022,” Golden said. “A debt fund, for example, they’re not necessarily tied to that. They can raise new capital and won't be tied to these pre-2022 vintages and can continue to originate loans.”
)
Not every public lender is pulling back. Catherwood said Starwood, Ladder Capital and TPG RE Finance Trust remain in growth mode because their portfolios carry less legacy baggage, even as Starwood weighs its dividend.
Wall Street has already punished the rest. Mortgage REIT book values are down about 30% this cycle, and the stocks trade at 50% to 60% of book value, close to a trough, said Jade Rahmani, a managing director at Keefe, Bruyette & Woods.
The market has priced in another half-point Fed hike expected in December, he said.
“It’s clear to say the market is pricing in some significant losses,” Rahmani said. “Moving 50 basis points at this point is not going to be the straw that broke the camel’s back.”
The next round of pain is more likely to come from apartments than offices, particularly Class-B and C properties, he said.
“That risks sort of a second round of stress on these portfolios,” Rahmani said. “They seem to have dealt with their office challenges, but there are surely multifamily loans that have been modified and extended in hopes of lower rates. And now, we're facing higher rates.”
Golden said slow lending is likely to continue if rates stay volatile, and some borrowers who can’t or won’t put in more equity could walk away.
“I wouldn’t be surprised to see more keys coming back,” she said.
Even if rates stabilize, Catherwood said a handful of public lenders will still be working through legacy loans into 2028. Another Fed hike in December would add pressure, he said, but he doesn't see it as a turning point.
“I don’t think it’s a cataclysmic event,” Catherwood said. “It’s a speed bump to get through these resolutions.”
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)