Service Properties Trust rejected a $2B offer for its hotel portfolio that would have accelerated its plans to transition to a pure-play triple-net lease REIT.
)
The board, including all six independent trustees, unanimously agreed that offloading the portfolio would not be in the best interests of its shareholders, according to a letter published Friday.
Jim Koehler’s TKO made an unsolicited offer for 93 of the REIT’s assets on Oct. 7. The $2B all-cash bid exceeds SVC's entire market capitalization of less than $1B.
Rather than taking the offer, the company plans to retain its 77 hotels before selling them starting next year.
Service Properties Trust, which is managed by The RMR Group and trades under the ticker SVC, expects that the hotels will grow earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization by approximately $109M within 12 to 24 months, according to the letter. Doing so will allow the REIT to achieve higher sales prices, the board argued.
SVC began selling assets in 2025 to pay down debts. In the third quarter, the company reported a net loss of $87.9M, down further from a $46.9M loss during the same period last year. Its funds from operations, a core measure of cash flow for REITs, were $0.31 per share, down from $0.92 a year prior.
This year, SVC said it completed 14 of the 15 planned hotel sales for $116.7M combined. It is marketing two more hotels, according to its third-quarter investor presentation.
TKO followed up on its offer on Oct. 15, stating that the investment firm “is prepared to deliver proof of funds demonstrating its strong financial capacity and wherewithal to complete the proposed transaction.” It offered to deposit $50M into escrow to demonstrate its commitment.
“Despite submitting an all cash offer, TKO contends that it has received no meaningful response from SVC,” the company said in the statement. “TKO maintains that this silence is difficult to reconcile with SVC's public statements regarding its intention to sell its hotel assets.”
SVC originally revealed its rejection in an investor presentation on Nov. 5, claiming that the $2B offer significantly undervalues the portfolio.
Activist Blackwells Capital challenged the decision in a letter published a day later. It argued that RMR's financial ties to hotel operator Sonesta International Hotels create conflicts of interest and that a sale could trigger substantial management termination or transition payments, potentially giving RMR an incentive to resist a deal.
The letter, penned by Blackwells Chief Investment Officer Jason Aintabi, highlighted that SVC’s share price is down 85% in five years and 35% in a year.
“A board that tells its owners the hotels alone are worth significantly more than $2.0 billion has exactly one legitimate way to prove it: a genuine process, run in the open, by unconflicted trustees," Aintabi said in a statement released alongside the letter.
Adjusted hotel EBITDA for SVC’s 77 retained hotels was $41.1M in the third quarter, a 16% increase year-over-year.
The REIT said it has invested $628M in those assets since 2023, which has driven an 8% increase in revenue per available room.
In its Friday letter responding to Blackwells, the board claimed that the results illustrate that the hotels could be worth between $3B and $4.1B in aggregate.
“The Board believes that allowing this growth to take hold before selling offers the opportunity to realize significantly higher proceeds for shareholders than selling the hotels today,” the board wrote.
In the last five days, SVC's stock price climbed more than 13%, including 2% between market open and noon on Monday.
SVC plans to begin selling the properties individually or in small portfolios and expects to offload all of the properties by the end of 2028.
“The Board would seriously consider credible proposals for the Retained Hotels that would accelerate SVC’s transition to a de-levered pure play triple net lease REIT, provided that, in the Board’s judgment, they appropriately value the Retained Hotels and are in the best interests of SVC and all its shareholders,” the board wrote. “TKO’s proposal simply did not meet these standards.”
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)