BTR Operators Push For Treasury To Loosen Rules As Consolidation Looms

The build-to-rent sector is facing a second round of wrangling with the government after a hard-fought battle with lawmakers over the summer to keep the industry from facing steep regulations as part of the housing bill that made its way through Congress. 

BTR operators and industry advocates are pushing for changes to proposed rules from the Department of the Treasury that will dictate how the restrictions on BTR operators from the 21st Century Road to Housing Act are implemented. Operators in the sector say the rules could hamper new development and, regardless of what’s adjusted, expect consolidation to sweep across the sector.

“Hopefully that gets adjusted, because that will have a severe impact on capital flows and ultimately the building of new homes and new rental communities,” Richard Ross, CEO of Atlanta-based Quinn Residences, said of the proposed rules. 

The proposed regulations require large institutional investors, which are defined in the original legislation as firms with at least 350 single-family rental units, to adopt written BTR programs before they purchase a community and would preclude BTR operators from purchasing properties more than 18 months after the home received its certificate of occupancy. 

Ross, whose firm has developed or purchased 5,200 homes across 34 communities since its founding in 2020, wrote in a letter submitted as a public comment to Treasury that it can frequently take two years or more to stabilize a newly built community.

The two new rules would make it more difficult for homebuilders to sell excess inventory to build-to-rent operators, hampering activity in a pool of properties that BTR operators have long dipped into, Ross told Bisnow. 

His letter was one of more than 100 public comments filed so far. Other operators and industry groups, including the nonpartisan trade association National Rental Home Council, are still crafting their own submissions, CEO Adrianne Todman said. The public comment period closes on Nov. 23. 

“The Treasury Department has put forward some thoughtful rules where they're trying to thread the needle very carefully by making sure they are properly implementing the legislative ban on investors being able to buy homes but also making sure that it's not having any detrimental impacts to the housing marketplace and particularly the rental marketplace,” Todman said.

The push to shift the rules follows the first bout of uncertainty that shrouded the BTR sector when the Road to Housing legislation was originally being debated. The bill debuted with strict restrictions on the BTR business model that threatened to upend the sector. It took intense lobbying for the rules to shift. 

Investment in the sector was severely scaled back during that debate, as investors waited to see what the final legislation would include. 

“When there was a threat to being able to build new rental supply via build-to-rent, we saw that there was millions of dollars and thousands of units that went on the sidelines and that those resources were frozen,” Todman said. “Those resources are thawing out a bit, and we want to make sure that they thaw out even more.” 

The push for clear guidelines gained new momentum after Democrats won control of both houses of Congress in the midterm elections. Some senators-elect ran on campaigns explicitly against corporate ownership of homes, including James Talarico in Texas and Josh Turek in Iowa. 

Talarico’s website includes a call to “ban Wall Street from buying up housing stock to enrich wealthy investors while making it harder for families to afford homes,” and Turek’s platform includes a call to ban private equity firms from purchasing single-family homes. 

The Road to Housing legislation adds new compliance standards and an element of federal oversight, including public reporting requirements for large operators, that are expected to lead to a wave of buyouts and mergers across the sector. The consolidation is likely coming regardless of where Treasury lands on its rules, as smaller players are squeezed by costs that large operators that benefit from economies of scale can more easily absorb. 

“You put it all together, it's just a tougher backdrop for them to really justify their existence,” said Haendel St. Juste, equity research analyst at Mizuho, who upgraded the two major publicly traded single-family rental firms to outperform in September. 

New compliance costs for operators with at least 350 units but not thousands will raise operating costs for smaller BTR firms around the same time that the private equity funds backing those platforms reach the end of their lives. 

A substantial amount of the debt backing private BTR and SFR firms was issued around five to seven years ago and is reaching the end of its natural life cycle, leaving operators facing significantly higher debt service costs to stay in business, St. Juste said. 

Nontraded SFR REIT VineBrook Homes Trust suspended share buybacks earlier this month after ending a tender offer that drew three times as many shares as the REIT sought to buy. VineBrook, which has 20,500 units in 21 states, flagged an upcoming $650.8M debt maturity within a year as a driving factor behind the shift in strategy.

For Invitation Homes and American Homes 4 Rent, the two biggest publicly traded single-family rental firms, the legislation creates a unique and sizable rollup opportunity, St. Juste wrote in a September analysis. 

The two REITs have trailed the broader REIT index by about 13 percentage points this year, according to Mizuho’s September report, and investors see upside potential in the wide gap that exists between the firms’ public valuations and the value of the properties in their portfolios. 

The REITs have been using that gap to sell homes and buy back stock at an attractive valuation, a trend that is expected to continue into 2027. Invitation Homes sold 658 homes in the third quarter and acquired 216 homes, with net proceeds of $245M funding stock buybacks.

“With the new $500 million share repurchase program our board just authorized, we intend to keep funding buybacks with home sale proceeds whenever our stock trades at a meaningful discount to the value of our homes,” CEO Dallas Tanner said in a statement released with third-quarter results on Oct. 28. 

Activist investor Land & Buildings Investment Management, which owns shares in Invitation Homes, released a letter Monday calling on the REIT to continue selling homes to return at least $2B a year to shareholders through stock buybacks or dividends.

Invitation Homes has repurchased $850M in stock across the last four quarters, according to Q3 disclosures. American Homes 4 Rent repurchased $75M in stock in the third quarter and sold 291 homes.

Stock in American Homes 4 Rent is up roughly 2% this year, while Invitation Homes is down by around the same amount. Both stocks are trading at large discounts to their net asset values, which St. Juste and Land & Buildings CEO Jonathan Litt see as a continued opportunity to shed assets at a premium to fund buybacks.

Investment in the BTR space still hasn’t returned to the levels it was at before Congress began the debate around the housing legislation. The latest discussion around the rules at Treasury has given investors more reason to pull back, Ross said. 

While some newcomers to Congress have taken a hard line against corporate ownership of housing stock, the industry is focused on working with Treasury to put out rules that represent the Congressional intent of the 21st Century Road to Housing Act, Todman said. 

“There's a fair amount of interest in making sure that build-to-rent units are properly exempted from the ban because of the concern of what it will do to future housing supplies,” she said. “That was expressed by many members of Congress, and we will be reminding Treasury of that.”

Continue reading this story with a free account

Log in or register
Sign up for more articles like this
Subscribe to Bisnow's National Newsletters
Related Stories

HSBC Sells $300M Of Data Center Debt Tied To Stargate Project At Big Discount

Burger King Takes 'Have It Your Way' Approach To Restaurant Renovations

Syndicator Firm Faces Foreclosure On Atlanta Apartments Tied To $366M Loan

Data Centers Head Out To Sea To Find Power And Avoid Pushback

How Regency Centers Turned A YouTube Series Into A Resource Small-Business Owners Actually Use

Wall Street's Big CRE Lenders Are Pulling Back While Private Credit Fights For Deals

Service Properties Trust Rejects $2B Cash Bid, Claims Hotel Portfolio Could Be Worth Double

Blackstone's Data Center REIT Makes First Investment With $5B AWS Deal

Where Developers Are Trying To Lease Public Lands To Build Data Centers

Members Of Congress Have Questions For Brookfield After Its Mass Mobile Home Purchase

SpaceX Unveils $74B Data Center Plans In Texas, Arizona

Shareholders Reject H&R REIT Breakup