The Last Stand: 6 Real Estate Holdouts That Drove Developers Mad

The Chinese have a special name for real estate holdouts. A nail house refers to a property within an area where developers want to build a new project, but owners refuse to sell, like a nail stuck in wood. Love them or hate them, here are some of the most iconic real estate holdouts in recent history.

Gate Tower Building in Osaka

This building is easily recognized by the Hanshin Expressway onramp located within (yes, within) the tower. In the early 1980s, redevelopment of the was approved by the city but building permits stalled because the highway was in planning. Property rights holders negotiated with the Hanshin Expressway for five years before agreeing to jointly develop Gate Tower Building and the highway.
Gate Tower Building In Osaka

This 16-story building is easily recognizable by the Hanshin Expressway on-ramp within (yes, within) the tower. In the early 1980s, redevelopment of the property was approved by the city but building permits stalled because the highway was in planning. Property rights holders negotiated with the developers of the Hanshin Expressway for five years before agreeing to jointly develop the Gate Tower Building and the highway.

Austin Spriggs House in Washington, DC

Austin Spriggs House in Washington, D.C.
Austin Spriggs House in Washington, DC

In 2003, architect Austin Spriggs refused developers who offered him $3M for his row house to turn the site into offices. Eventually the developers decided to build around the structure. In 2011, the property sold to DC-based Zusin Development and New York-based Sivan Properties for $800K and became a restaurant. In 2016, the partnership sold the property to a New York investor for nearly $4M.

Wu Ping House in Chongqing

Wu Ping House in Chongqing
Wu Ping House in Chongqing

Wu Ping became a Chinese celebrity in 2004 after refusing to sell her Chongqing home to a shopping mall developer. Close to 300 families in the area also refused to sell, but Ping would not vacate her home even after the state told her to do so. In 2007, Ping’s home was demolished and her family received 1 million yuan and a new apartment in a settlement.

Hess Triangle in New York City

Hess Triangle in New York City
Hess Triangle in New York City

When local government tried to acquire David Hess’ Voorhis apartment estate in the 1910s through eminent domain, Hess refused to sell. He was unswayed by New York’s initiative to demolish 300 properties to expand subway services, but by 1914 the city acquired his property. Years later, Hess’ heirs discovered that the incomplete survey missed a small corner of land that was never acquired. A mosaic installed on the site in 1922 provides the ultimate defiance and reads, “Property Of The Hess Estate Which Has Never Been Dedicated For Public Purposes.” Though the land was bought by Village Cigars in 1938 for $1K, the plaque remains.

St. Joseph Catholic Church in San Antonio

St. Joseph Catholic Church in San Antonio
St. Joseph Catholic Church in San Antonio

In Downtown San Antonio, you can worship at a Roman Catholic parish and shop in adjacent properties. In 1944, department store Joske’s offered to buy the church grounds with the intent to develop retail shops that would later become the Shops at Rivercenter. Churchgoers unanimously refused to sell, forcing Joske’s to develop around three sides of the Gothic Revival church. The unofficial nickname of the parish became St. Joske’s.

Edith Macefield House in Seattle

Edith Macefield House in Seattle
Edith Macefield House in Seattle

In 2006, developers tried to buy Edith Macefield’s Seattle home for a handsome sum to build a five-story development. Macefield rose to national prominence when she would not sell, causing the development to be built around her home. Macefield died in 2008 after rejecting about $1M to buy her 1,050 SF home. Now, the home sits next to an LA Fitness and whether the home will be demolished or preserved is unknown. Macefield called the home Whitewood Cottage, but most of the world knows it as the inspiration for the Disney Pixar film "Up," though screenwriting for the film began two years before she refused to sell.

Continue reading this story with a free account

Log in or register
Sign up for more articles like this
Subscribe to Bisnow's National Newsletters
Related Stories

Wall Street Impatient For Big Tech Returns On Data Center Spending

As AI Adoption Ramps Up, Half A Million Property Managers Are In The Crosshairs

Treasuries Hover Around 4.7% As Wall Street Questions If Warsh Is A 'Dove In Hawk's Clothing'

Avison Young Had Assets Frozen By Bank Over Unpaid Taxes

Camden Property Trust Sells West Coast Portfolio, Clears $1.5B Target

Churchill Downs Plans To Sell 9 Casinos, Focus On Horse Racing

How Long Island Projects Can Cut Through Red Tape And Community Opposition To Cross The Finish Line

Bringing Stability And Savings To CRE Insurance Through Working Layer

More Hotel Owners In Need Of Cash Are Getting It From The Big Brands

Former Arms Dealer Targeting Heartland Apartment Takeover Files For Bankruptcy

SEC Charges REIT, Its Founders With Alleged $152M Fraud Scheme

Equinix Ramps Up Spending Plans Amid Faster-Than-Expected AI Shift