To Rein In Costs, Philly Affordable Housing Players Look To Become 'Less Reliant On Consultants'

Affordable housing developers are looking for new ways to make projects pencil as they face soaring costs caused by factors they can't control — from global market conditions to government regulations.

In Philadelphia, some developers of low-income and attainable housing buildings are turning to one area they do have control over: doing more work in-house.

Four people are seated on a stage, each holding microphones, engaged in a panel discussion, with a statue and clock visible in the background.
Photo credit: Bisnow/Noah Zucker
Evolution Sustainability Group's Chuck Hurchalla, Aedera Cos.' Alison Carey, Riverwards Group's Mo Rushdy and Pennrose's Timothy Henkel

“Sometimes we hire consultants to help us put these deals together because they're very complicated,” HACE President Maria Gonzalez said during Bisnow’s Philadelphia Affordable Housing Conference on Tuesday at One North Broad.

“Trying to bring the capacity and skills in-house so that you are less reliant on consultants, that helps us be able to have additional savings. We don't have to use our developer fees to pay a consultant for the product.”

Rising construction material costs, elevated interest rates and ballooning insurance premiums are impacting the entire real estate sector. On top of that, Gonzalez said affordable housing nonprofits like HACE rely heavily on federal programs such as the low-income housing tax credit, which includes cumbersome guidelines that bloat construction costs far beyond what is seen in market-rate housing.

Six people seated on a stage participating in a panel discussion in a formal setting with a large statue in the background.
Photo credit: Bisnow/Noah Zucker
Select Redevelopment's Travis Seal, Philadelphia Housing Development Corp.'s David Thomas, LeadingAge PA's Garry Pezzano, NewCourtland's Joe Duffey, TD Bank's Sue Taylor and HACE's Maria Gonzalez

But even in the market-rate sector, Riverwards Group Managing Partner Mo Rushdy said “paper developers” who bring in third-party contractors to build out projects can’t survive in many of Philly’s outer neighborhoods.

While rents there are lower than in highly desirable neighborhoods like Center City, the construction costs are the same.

“If you look at the upside on market-rate stuff that's in these neighborhoods, we're talking about 6% to 8%,” Rushdy said.

“Can you imagine how thin these deals are in terms of profit?” he added. “That upside is just enough to pay the equity, and the developer's left with little to nothing. So we have to be dependent on ourselves to grow.”

That is why he built the firm on a full-service model from design to property management.

While Gonzalez said it is sometimes possible to save some money on construction by using nonunion workers, she said that isn’t a viable route for every project in an organized labor stronghold like Philadelphia.

Four people sitting on chairs with microphones, engaged in a panel discussion on a stage with a large statue in the background.
Photo credit: Bisnow/Noah Zucker
The Michaels Organization's Jonathan Lubonski, Project HOME's Donna Bullock, Pennsylvania Housing Finance Agency's Robin Wiessmann and the city of Philadelphia's Jessie Lawrence

In-house asset management teams are a relatively new concept for the affordable housing sector, according to Timothy Henkel, CEO of national development firm Pennrose.

“About 10 years ago, owner-operators of affordable housing began to create asset management departments because of the scale, because it becomes data-rich,” he said.

In a sector defined by increasingly tight margins, Henkel said there is little room for error. The teams made up of tax and utility specialists can catch and address issues quickly before they become grave.

But they aren’t available to most smaller affordable housing owners and operators, so they may not be a solution to the industry’s operating woes.

“If our portfolio weren’t big enough, we wouldn’t be able to afford that,” Henkel said. “That's something that I know challenges some of our partners who operate on their own or are partners with us in parts of their portfolios.”

Continue reading this story with a free account

Log in or register
Sign up for more articles like this
Subscribe to Bisnow's Philadelphia Newsletters
Related Stories

Rent Concessions Dip As Fewer Apartments Come Online

AvalonBay, Equity Residential Selling Boston Towers As Part Of Merger Settlement

Shapiro Turns On Pennsylvania Data Centers With Restrictive Executive Order

IRES Looks To More Forward Funding As Resi Market Gathers Pace

Knightvest Capital Acquires 3 Multifamily Communities In Austin

Judge Approves $70M Sale Of Philly's Largest Office Complex

Millennium Partners Lands $281M Loan For Winthrop Center Tower

Vivmark Details Merged Entity, Becomes Largest U.S. Apartment REIT By Far

Brookfield, SWI Form $694M Multifamily Venture, Plan $500M In Sales

3 Suburban Philly Office Buildings With Strong Occupancy Hit The Market

Housing Shortage, Population Growth Draw Developers To Lehigh Valley

Tax Break Fight Threatens Development In Housing-Starved Long Island