New City Guidance Could Kill Rent Overcharge Lawsuits

Some of New York City’s biggest apartment owners notched a win this week after the city issued new guidance for calculating rent increases in stabilized apartments.

Tall modern glass building at 300 Ashland, viewed from street level with trees and a streetlight in the foreground.
300 Ashland Place, a property owned by Two Trees where attorneys claimed the landlord overcharged tenants of rent-stabilized units

Landlords that operate buildings with rent-stabilized units, including buildings with 421-a tax subsidies, have been facing lawsuits claiming that they overcharged tenants.

Defendants include Two Trees, former Gov. Eliot Spitzer’s firm and Rockrose — all of which have been named in a slew of suits filed since August.

But this week, the Division of Housing and Community Renewal updated its fact sheet for those landlords, effectively undermining the argument made by tenants and their lawyers.

“The updated fact sheet basically kicks the legs out from the claims that have been filed,” said YuhTyng Patka, co-chair of the NYC real estate tax and zoning incentives practice at Adler & Stachenfeld.

In the suits, landlords have faced claims that they collected more rent than they were legally entitled to.

The claims center on the math behind rent increases for rent-stabilized units. Prior to the 2019 Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act, landlords followed DHCR guidelines stating that increases could be calculated off the preferential rent, a term used to describe the full rent of an apartment without concessions.

HSTPA removed the distinction between preferential rents and rent concessions, The Real Deal reported. But DHCR didn’t issue guidance directing landlords to make their calculations any differently, attorneys told Bisnow.

Now, suits allege that rent increases for stabilized units should instead have been calculated based on the net effective rent, meaning the total rent collected when discounts are taken into account.

For example, if an apartment is rented at $5K a month but a tenant is given two months of free rent, that brings the net effective rent to $4K a month, said Jeffrey Goldman, founding and co-managing partner of Belkin Burden Goldman, the firm that has been defending landlords in some of these suits.

The argument that tenant attorneys are making is that the increase — limited to specific percentages by the Rent Guidelines Board — should be based on the $4K rather than the $5K in that case, he said.

Many landlords handed out concessions just like this to tenants in recent years, Goldman said, adding that it is still a frequent occurrence when a building is in its initial lease-up period if the building’s amenities aren’t available yet and during the slower leasing period in the winter months.

“That practice was longstanding. It was not uncommon,” Patka said. “It was known by [the NYC Department of Housing Preservation and Development] and DHCR, who did not say or do anything to discourage the practice.”

But an April ruling from New York County Supreme Court Judge Arlene Bluth, on a case known as Grey v. LIC Development Owner, changed the calculation for concessions, The Real Deal previously reported.

That decision set off a wave of lawsuits aimed at landlords including Fetner Properties, Gotham Organization, Douglaston Development and The Durst Organization, according to Adler & Stachenfeld data shared with Bisnow. One firm alone, Newman Ferrera, filed 21 such suits between August and early November, according to Adler & Stachenfeld.

However, the 2019 HSTPA law didn’t mention concessions, Adler & Stachenfeld NYC real estate tax and zoning incentives associate Zachary Nathanson said.

With DHCR’s publication of an updated fact sheet regarding calculating rent increases, Bluth’s ruling will make it much harder for many of those suits to proceed, Goldman said.

“Many of these lawsuits will now get dismissed,” he said. “The plaintiffs now are going to have to prove that the reasons for the rent concession did not exist at the time the rent concessions were offered.”

The updated guidance is good news for tenants, REBNY Executive Vice President of Public Policy Basha Gerhards said in a statement.

“Temporary rent relief can help New Yorkers stay in their homes and access new ones,” she said. “Clear rules help preserve the ability to offer temporary relief when tenants need it.”

Eli Weiss, principal at Joy Construction, said the new DHCR guidelines will calm landlords’ nerves.

“We only have one place to look for these regulations, which is the DHCR guidance,” he said. “Lack of guidance should not create industrywide lawsuits that have millions and millions of dollars in penalties behind them.”

But landlords can’t count on the lawsuits disappearing altogether, Nathanson said: Rent concessions aren’t necessarily considered preferential rent, but there are still contexts where they might be, according to DHCR. And the new guidelines leave some ambiguity as to what those conditions are, he said. 

There is also an incentive for lawyers to keep pursuing some of the suits, he said.

Cases against buildings that have rent-stabilized units but no 421-a subsidy can only try to recoup the amount that tenants allegedly overpaid, he said. But for buildings with the tax break, the suits claim they could pursue the amount that the developer hasn't had to pay in real estate taxes — meaning that a payout would be larger, Nathanson said.

“I very highly doubt that the litigation that's currently open will stop,” he said. “I do wonder, though, if it slows down the seeming acceleration of new cases, because they have lost one of the big pillars on which their case stands.”

Continue reading this story with a free account

Log in or register
Sign up for more articles like this
Subscribe to Bisnow's New York Newsletters
Related Stories

LAHSA To Return $150M Of HUD Funding In Finalized Settlement

Investor Appetite, Rising Costs Push Rosslyn-Ballston Developers Toward Low-Density Housing

Arada Lands £2.7B Deal To Unlock 5,000-Home Royal Docks Scheme

Syndicator Firm Faces Foreclosure On Atlanta Apartments Tied To $366M Loan

Chetrit's 26 Broadway Office Tower Has Value Slashed By 68%

Zara Founder Makes Another Massive Chicago Splash With Gold Coast Apartment Buy

Cities Regain Balance With Developers Over Live Local Act Restrictions

Mall Redevelopments Are Bringing More Urban Living To Chicago's Suburbs

Insurance Pricing Piles Pressure On Houston's Older Apartments

Rockefeller Group Sells Golden Triangle Apartment High-Rise For Nearly $91M

Music Venue Backed By Mumford & Sons Member To Open On Williamsburg Waterfront

Construction Site Next To Collapsed Building That Killed 8 Previously Violated Safety Precautions