Mamdani Admin Sues Bronx Landlords, Claiming Unpaid Fines Amount To Fraud

Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s administration is testing a new strategy to go after landlords who persistently fail to address violations and pay fines.

Police officers and officials in suits escort a woman in a brown coat down a city street lined with autumn trees.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani's administration is testing a new legal strategy to enforce laws against landlords who repeatedly fail to pay judgments and address repeat hazard violations.

The city filed a lawsuit Wednesday in Bronx County Supreme Court against landlords Barry Singer and Daniel Caller, claiming they have committed fraud under the False Claims Act. The legal action is the first time the city is going after property owners under the 21-year-old law.

The duo owes the city nearly $1.1M for repairs carried out by agencies in buildings with severe violations, according to the complaint. Because those debts go back at least three years across multiple properties controlled by Singer and Caller, the Mamdani administration argues the landlords knowingly left their debts to the city unpaid and hid behind LLCs to avoid coughing up the cash.

“We will not stand idly by while landlords neglect their buildings and leave tenants in dangerous living conditions for decades,” Mamdani said in a statement. “When the same old tools fail to deliver results, we will use new strategies to hold noncompliant landlords accountable and win justice for tenants.”

The FCA, introduced in 2005 by then-Mayor Michael Bloomberg, was intended to help New Yorkers recoup cash lost to fraud. But in a first, the city is using the law to go after Singer, who has appeared repeatedly on the Public Advocate Office's annual “Worst Landlords” list, and Caller to address “dangerous conditions” in their buildings, as previous enforcement efforts have fallen short.

Singer's buildings have racked up violations including facades with “potential to collapse,” rusting fire escapes, severe cracks and electrical work without permits, the city’s attorneys allege in the suit. Singer is responsible for paying those fees because he owns the LLCs that control the buildings, the suit says.

Specifically, the city’s attorneys argue that Singer and Caller committed fraud against the city by evading payments they owed the government for carrying out emergency repairs, curtailing pests and vermin, and defaulting on judgments issued in civil and administrative proceedings.

The city is seeking more than $10M overall to address violations in 11 properties in the Bronx and Brooklyn and for unpaid legal judgments stemming from those violations, attorneys for the city said in the suit.

The strategy was cooked up with legal advocacy group Housing Rights Initiative, according to a release from the Mayor’s Office.

The Singer-owned LLCs that control the buildings where city departments have been dispatched to make repairs have racked up debts of $1.06M to the city for those fixes, according to the filing. The FCA allows the city to claim triple that figure, or $3.18M, in compensation. 

The suit also says Singer’s actions constitute nuisance abatement law violations. Total liability for those penalties exceeds $8M, according to the suit.

If the city succeeds in using the FCA to punish landlords for unaddressed violations, the move could become one more enforcement tool for the Mamdani administration.

“Barry Singer has left his tenants in deplorable conditions for years,” NYC Director of the Mayor’s Office to Protect Tenants Cea Weaver said in a statement. “We are taking action to protect our neighbors, recoup payments for repairs that the City has been forced to make because Singer wouldn’t.”

Targeting landlords of buildings where tenants are living in substandard conditions has been a pillar of Mamdani's housing policy in his first year in office. His administration held a series of “Rental Ripoff” hearings in the spring, asking tenants to share stories of negligent property owners, and has urged renters to organize and form tenant unions to stand up to the powerful real estate industry.

Continue reading this story with a free account

Log in or register
Sign up for more articles like this
Subscribe to Bisnow's New York Newsletters
Related Stories

Sherwood Equities Sells Hudson Yards Development Site For $100M: The N.Y. Deal Sheet

Phoenix Developers Turn To Vacant Schools For Affordable Housing

GO Residential Charts A New Course After H&R Deal Sinks

Russell Galbut To Submit Miami Beach Projects Weeks After Scrapping Earlier Plans

New City Guidance Could Kill Rent Overcharge Lawsuits

LAHSA To Return $150M Of HUD Funding In Finalized Settlement

Investor Appetite, Rising Costs Push Rosslyn-Ballston Developers Toward Low-Density Housing

Syndicator Firm Faces Foreclosure On Atlanta Apartments Tied To $366M Loan

Chetrit's 26 Broadway Office Tower Has Value Slashed By 68%

Zara Founder Makes Another Massive Chicago Splash With Gold Coast Apartment Buy

Cities Regain Balance With Developers Over Live Local Act Restrictions

Mall Redevelopments Are Bringing More Urban Living To Chicago's Suburbs