Almost exactly a year after the developer planning a mixed-use mall redevelopment sued a Chester County municipal board for blocking its project, the developer has received permission to move forward.
)
Judge Sarah Black ruled in favor of Abrams Realty & Development in a Friday decision regarding the future of the now-shuttered Exton Square Mall.
She wrote that an "illogical train of thought” led the West Whiteland Board of Supervisors to reject the firm’s master plan application. The developer plans to demolish much of the enclosed shopping center and construct a mixed-use campus including more than 700 residential units and 280K SF of retail.
ARD owner Peter Abrams told Bisnow he was glad to see the court rule in his favor and is looking forward to bringing a senior living community, townhomes and new retail space to fruition.
While a delivery date for the project remains up in the air, he said if the upcoming permitting process with the township goes smoothly, demolition and construction on the roughly 1M SF project could start as soon as this coming spring.
“We are beyond relieved,” Abrams said.
“The judge was pretty clear: ‘Don’t screw with these guys anymore,’” he added.
Black found that the board of supervisors — which included just two members at the time of the October 2025 rejection, Rajesh Kumbhardare and Brian Dunn — made faulty rulings on a number of grounds. The board now includes those two members plus a third, Libby Madarasz.
The judge knocked the “paradoxical” rejection as vague, contradictory and not backed by hard facts.
The board cited concerns about traffic and potential strain on public utilities but also appealed to a broad sense of the project being out of line with constituents’ interests.
“There were hundreds of emails from our residents concerning traffic conditions,” Kumbhardare told Bisnow at the time of the rejection. “The density is more than what we would like there to be.”
The judge found only four individual objectors in the township’s records of public meetings and concluded that the master plan complied by right with the town center zoning ordinance as it existed at the time of the application.
The code was updated shortly thereafter to prevent the amount of density ARD proposed.
“This conclusion may be an attempt by the Board to retroactively apply a change in the Township’s density requirements to this particular application,” Black wrote.
“It is absurd to demand the Plaintiff explain why compliance with the zoning ordinance is in the best interests of the township,” she added. “Presumably, those ordinances were enacted to effectuate those interests.”
Kumbhardare declined Bisnow’s request for comment. Dunn and the township’s solicitor, Alex Baumler, didn't respond.
The yearlong legal saga has been a financial burden for ARD, which finalized its purchase of the property from PREIT for $34M in March 2025.
The developer was forced to carry the largely vacant mall for longer than expected. The vacancy-riddled property shuttered in June.
“Holding the property together given the condition that the property is in and continuing to carry it financially was not easy,” Abrams said.
“We’ve already been severely damaged financially by these actions.”
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)