Judge Hears Staples/Office Depot Merger Case’s Closing Arguments

The judge hearing closing arguments this week for Staples' proposed $6.3B Office Depot merger seemed unimpressed by the company's defense against the government’s antitrust challenge of the deal.

Staples' lawyer Diane Sullivan argued that the deal was needed for the companies to compete with Amazon in the office supply space.

"This merger has always been about keeping these 1980s companies relevant in a digital world," she said. "They're (Amazon) like a boulder rolling down a hill."

But Judge Emmet Sullivan pushed back against Staples' arguments, highlighting inaccurate reasoning several times by the office supply giant's lawyers, Reuters reports.

The merger saga of the US's two largest office supply companies has been a work in progress—stretching back almost 20 years—and the FTC hasn't budged over antitrust concerns.

While Staples has offered to divest itself of a chunk of its contract business, in a similar way it did in Europe to gain approval, Judge Sullivan remains unconvinced, suggesting the case is still too close to call. [Reuters]

Continue reading this story with a free account

Log in or register
Sign up for more articles like this
Subscribe to Bisnow's National Newsletters
Related Stories

'Doesn't Look Good': October CRE Sales Volume Slumps, Setting Up Weak Q4

Companies Led By 49ers CEO, Former Rockets Exec Launch Sports Real Estate Arm

Nvidia Tops Forecasts In First Report Without Jensen Huang, But Gets Choosier About Backing Data Centers

GO Residential Charts A New Course After H&R Deal Sinks

BTR Operators Push For Treasury To Loosen Rules As Consolidation Looms

HSBC Sells $300M Of Data Center Debt Tied To Stargate Project At Big Discount

Burger King Takes 'Have It Your Way' Approach To Restaurant Renovations

Syndicator Firm Faces Foreclosure On Atlanta Apartments Tied To $366M Loan

Data Centers Head Out To Sea To Find Power And Avoid Pushback

How Regency Centers Turned A YouTube Series Into A Resource Small-Business Owners Actually Use

Macerich Acquires Oakridge Mall In San Jose For $250M

Shopping Center In Metro Phoenix Sells For $116.7M