The clock is running out for large amounts of CRE debt that had maturity dates pushed out during the wave of modifications that became known as extend-and-pretend.
)
Property owners with CMBS debt have claimed nearly $100B worth of loan modifications since 2022, and 1 in 5 dollars still outstanding from those modifications is once again delinquent, according to Trepp. The return to distressed status for some debt comes as lenders more broadly shift away from modifications, with foreclosures, payoffs and cures becoming more common.
Servicers have modified 966 CMBS loans with a combined $98.3B balance since 2022, with the busiest year being 2025, with $28.4B modified. Servicers added 141 loans with $17.4B to the stack so far this year as many pivot toward workouts, Trepp found.
Years of extensions have pushed the share of modified loans up to 7.3% of the total outstanding CMBS balance, a steep rise from the 1.3% of debt at the end of 2022. Loans modified during the global pandemic accounted for 26% of the loans that were once again modified since 2022.
Roughly half the CMBS debt modified since 2022 has matured, with $49.8B still outstanding. Of the remaining balance, 21.3% is delinquent, more than four times the rate for loans that were never modified, according to Trepp.
Loans with modifications are more likely to be delinquent across every asset class, with the widest imbalance in lodging and retail, where roughly a quarter of modified loans are delinquent compared to 1% to 2% of loans that were never modified.
Delinquencies in the office sector reflect broader weakness for the asset class, with 19% of modified loans delinquent compared to 10% of loans that were never modified.
Paydowns were part of 22% of modifications since 2022, typically amounting to 5.4% of the loan balance, according to Trepp. No more than 49% of modifications included a paydown or a higher reserve requirement.
Loan extensions were rare in 2022 at 22% of modifications but accounted for most of the volume by 2024, Trepp found in a separate analysis. Roughly 1 in 5 loans modified in 2024 was back with a special servicer within a year, more than double the rate in 2022.
Some owners are finding a workable deal, with 24% of payoffs this year being resolved balances, up from 11% in 2023. But owners have for years waited for a recovery in prices that has not arrived, Trepp analysts wrote. And lenders' willingness to keep waiting is wearing thin.
“The middle way, a modification that buys time, has lost the most ground since 2024,” they wrote.
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)