191 Peachtree Loan Moves To Special Servicing After Banyan Misses Maturity

A loan tied to Atlanta’s fourth-tallest skyscraper has entered special servicing after the borrower said it couldn’t pay off the balance at maturity.

A skyline view of 191 Peachtree Tower in Downtown Atlanta

Rialto Capital took over the $175.5M loan last month on Banyan Street Capital’s 191 Peachtree Tower due to “imminent monetary default,” according to Morningstar Analytics. Banyan purchased the 50-story, 1.2M SF tower in 2016 for $268M.

The transfer is a setback for one of the largest office towers in the Southeast and comes as office landlords and tenants in the region struggle to stay afloat amid higher interest rates. 

Banyan didn’t respond to a request for comment.

When Banyan acquired 191 Peachtree, the tower was 90% leased. A decade later, occupancy shrank to less than 60% and cash flow withered more than 30%, Bisnow reported in April. 

Banyan is one of a host of landlords in the region facing looming maturing debt. According to Avison Young, $5B in loans tied to Metro Atlanta properties are set to mature between this quarter and the end of 2028, forcing owners to decide whether to try to sell or refinance.

Central business district office values are on average nearly half their worth since the peak in March 2022, Avison Young found, leaving owners with “significantly less equity” in their properties. 191 Peachtree’s Fulton County appraised value was $194.7M this year, down from $231M in 2023 and a 27% drop from its 2016 purchase price. 

Banyan lost its key 262K SF tenant, Deloitte, in 2024, which dropped occupancy below 70%, Morningstar said. Last year, its largest tenant, law firm Ogletree Deakens, inked a new lease at the nearby Bank of America Plaza, with plans to vacate its 52,500 SF at 191 Peachtree.

Professional services firm Forvis Mazars is vacating its 45K SF at 191 Peachtree to move to nearly half that space in Midtown, the Atlanta Business Chronicle reported in August. 

191 Peachtree is in Downtown Atlanta, a submarket that has seen an exodus of office tenants over the past half a decade into other parts of the metro area, especially to Midtown.

According to Morningstar Credit, Morgan Stanley originated the $175.5M loan for the building at 3.73% in 2016. The loan was subsequently divided into three separate CMBS tranches. 

In April, Fitch Ratings flagged the loan on 191 as a loan of concern because of falling occupancy and upcoming rollover and said Banyan would face difficulty in refinancing given both metrics. Fitch downgraded a Morgan Stanley CMBS pool due in part to the 191 Peachtree loan’s upcoming maturity. The loan attached to 191 Peachtree was the third-largest among the pool. 

Continue reading this story with a free account

Log in or register
Sign up for more articles like this
Subscribe to Bisnow's Atlanta Newsletters
Related Stories

GPE Completes £369M City Sale: The London Deal Sheet

ERock Moving HQ With 72K SF Lease At Central Park Post Oak

UBS Signs First Lease At Stonelake Capital's Spec Office Tower In Uptown Dallas

Office REIT Sells Reston Property To Local Firm For 30% Of 2014 Price

Voya Financial Relocating Atlanta Office From 40-Year Home

Private Equity Lags REITs In Getting CRE Portfolios Up To Market Speed

Congress Puts Up $216M For Energy Department Relocation From Forrestal

'Doesn't Look Good': October CRE Sales Volume Slumps, Setting Up Weak Q4

GO Residential Charts A New Course After H&R Deal Sinks

Investor Appetite, Rising Costs Push Rosslyn-Ballston Developers Toward Low-Density Housing

Syndicator Firm Faces Foreclosure On Atlanta Apartments Tied To $366M Loan

Austin Office Campus Lands $228M Refinancing Deal