Sutton Place Developer Risked It All And Lost

Foster + Partners

Joe Beninati, the developer behind the troubled Sutton Place supertall, had hoped the project would establish him as one of New York’s real estate heavyweights.

Joe had only a series of relatively small projects in Connecticut under his belt last year, when he bought three apartment buildings on East 58th St to lay the groundwork for his planned 1,000-foot tower.

Eager to get the ball rolling, Joe took a big risk: he borrowed $147M at a 30% interest rate from Gamma Real Estate, a lender with a track record of playing hardball when its terms aren’t met, Crain’s reports. Joe turned down offers from top builders like DDG and CIM Group to partner on the project.

After a string of complications and over-budget spending, Joe’s Bauhouse Group was unable to keep the momentum going and defaulted on the Gamma loan. The lender might’ve been banking on that all along, Crain's reports, especially given onerous terms like the $45M “exit fee” tucked into the contract.

Joe has since filed for bankruptcy and is suing Gamma, alleging the lender improperly tried to meddle in the foreclosure bidding process to snatch the development for itself.

For now, Gamma’s foreclosure has been staved off by the bankruptcy, and it remains to be seen how the various lawsuits surrounding the property will shake out. [Crain’s]

Continue reading this story with a free account

Log in or register
Sign up for more articles like this
Subscribe to Bisnow's New York Newsletters
Related Stories

Delaware Statutory Trust Fundraising Jumps 27% From 2025

Tishman Speyer Retakes Chrysler Building, Plans $235M Renovation

Activist Investor Buys Stake In Empire State Building Owner

DRA Buys Stake In 1301 Sixth Ave. At $1.3B Valuation: The N.Y. Deal Sheet

CRE Finance Sentiment Index Falls To 3-Year Low As Economic Fears Mount

RN3 Enters Dutch Logistics Market With DHL Sale-Leaseback Deal

Major NYC Multifamily Firm Expands With Tech-Driven Operations

Hedge Fund Breaks NYC Record With $375-Per-SF Office Lease

High-Flying Midtown Office Market Back To Pre-Pandemic Health

Mamdani Officials, RGB Members Had Frequent Contact Before Rent Freeze, Communications Reveal

KKR's Chris Lee On Finding Opportunities As CRE Begins A 'Regime Change'

NYC Unveils The Places Where Council Members Can't Block Housing Anymore