Yellowstone Lands $326M To Turn Former Hell's Kitchen Migrant Center Hotel Into Apartments

Opportunistic investor Isaac Hera has netted a huge construction loan from Barings to convert a Hell’s Kitchen hotel into apartments.

The 600-key Watson Hotel at 440 W. 57th St., which opportunistic investor Yellowstone plans to turn into 312 apartments.
The 600-Key Watson Hotel At 440 W. 57Th St., Which Opportunistic Investor Yellowstone Plans To Turn Into 312 Apartments.

Barings provided a $326M mortgage to Yellowstone Real Estate Investments, Hera's private equity firm, to turn 440 W. 57th St. into 312 apartments, PincusCo reported.

Yellowstone acquired the roughly 600-room property, formerly known as the Watson Hotel, in 2021 from its former lender for around $175M — at the time the highest pandemic-era price paid for any Manhattan hotel, Bloomberg previously reported.

Yellowstone didn’t disclose its vision for the Watson at the time of purchase but submitted plans in 2023 for a residential conversion, which were approved last month.

As it was waiting for approval and financing, Yellowstone offered the Watson as a shelter during the city’s migrant crisis under a contract that ran until June before it was nixed by then-Mayor Eric Adams. It provided some of the 16,000 hotel rooms estimated to have been used to house migrants who crossed the southern U.S. border and were bused to the city from states like Texas.

Yellowstone didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment. Barings declined to comment.

The Watson Hotel acquisition wasn’t Yellowstone’s only headline-making acquisition during what turned out to be the market's bottom. Hera scooped up a note valued at $106M on the New Yorker hotel, famous for its iconic signage, in 2023.

The following year, it paid less than $200M to acquire the CMBS loan for 1740 Broadway. Blackstone acquired the 621K SF, 26-story Midtown office tower for $605M in 2014 but handed the keys over to Hera after the building's loan was placed with a special servicer.

Also in 2024, Yellowstone purchased the 697-room hotel at 541 Lexington Ave., the Maxwell, bidding $140.5M at a foreclosure auction two years after acquiring the debt tied to the shuttered hotel.

Continue reading this story with a free account

Log in or register
Sign up for more articles like this
Subscribe to Bisnow's New York Newsletters
Related Stories

Music Venue Backed By Mumford & Sons Member To Open On Williamsburg Waterfront

Construction Site Next To Collapsed Building That Killed 8 Previously Violated Safety Precautions

The Rockaways Rebuild After Decades Of Neglect

Emerald Equity's Rent-Stabilized Portfolio Returns To Lender Following Rejected Offer

Flagship IHG Times Square Hotel Nets $235M Loan: The N.Y. Deal Sheet

RXR Signs Investment Bank To 220K SF Lease In FiDi

NYC Claims Nearly Half Of State's Opportunity Zones, Putting New Neighborhoods In Play

New Jersey Is On The Verge Of Becoming An Industrial Landlord's Market

Higher Risk, Higher Rewards: Bouwinvest Leads Global Investors Back Into U.S. Offices

'More Know-How' Could Bring Houston More Conversions, Fewer Disasters

How Mamdani's Pied-à-Terre Tax Could Change NYC's High-End Rental Market

How New York CRE Can Find The 'Right Fit' In Its Capital Stack