Brooklyn Borough President Opposes Resi Tower Next To Botanic Garden

Brooklyn Botanic Garden, where another proposed development that could cast long shadows across greenhouses that are home to rare, light-sensitive plant species is facing political and public opposition.
Brooklyn Botanic Garden, Where Another Proposed Development That Could Cast Long Shadows Across Greenhouses That Are Home To Rare, Light-Sensitive Plant Species Is Facing Political And Public Opposition.

Proposals for a 14-story residential building that would tower over the Brooklyn Botanic Garden have run into local political opposition.

Continuum Co., led by Ian Bruce Eichner, has proposed developing a 475-unit residential property across the street from the gardens at 962-972 Franklin Ave.

But the site requires a rezoning to move ahead — and it may not get the political support it needs.

Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso said in a Friday morning post on social media platform X that he will oppose the proposal.

Today I disapproved 962-972 Franklin Ave.@BrooklynBotanic is sacred, and this one-of-a-kind community resource deserves one-of-a-kind consideration.

I will not support any development here that will create additional shadow impacts.

This proposal fails to meet that standard.

— Antonio Reynoso (@BKBPReynoso) July 26, 2024

Reynoso’s rationale is that the shadows cast by the proposed development would still implicate the nearby Jackie Robinson Playground and the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, with shadows threatening some of the thousands of rare plant species housed in the gardens.

“The Borough President believes that supply is a critical part of addressing the housing crisis — this is simply the wrong place [for] this proposed building because of its adjacency to a critical, public, sunlight-sensitive resource,” Reynoso wrote in a 14-page testimony that he linked to in his X post.

Reynoso’s disapproval of the project follows a June vote against the towers by Brooklyn’s Community Board 9.

The scenario is similar to one that Continuum faced in 2021 when it sought to build two 39-story rental buildings on the same site with a different address.

That proposal was crushed by public and political opposition following calculations that the towers would cast 4.5 hours of shade over the gardens every day, and the developers’ analysis in its environmental impact statement said the shadows “may affect the public’s use or enjoyment” of the space.

While the new proposal is different from its predecessor, Reynoso said in his testimony that the question he has to answer “is whether the applicant’s proposed actions are appropriate in their own right, not whether they are merely improved relative to the legally distinct 2021 application.”

Continue reading this story with a free account

Log in or register
Sign up for more articles like this
Subscribe to Bisnow's New York Newsletters
Related Stories

Camden Property Trust Sells West Coast Portfolio, Clears $1.5B Target

How Long Island Projects Can Cut Through Red Tape And Community Opposition To Cross The Finish Line

Bringing Stability And Savings To CRE Insurance Through Working Layer

Former Arms Dealer Targeting Heartland Apartment Takeover Files For Bankruptcy

SEC Charges REIT, Its Founders With Alleged $152M Fraud Scheme

Empire State Building Observation Deck Hemorrhaging Visitors, Value

Miami's Condo Craze Has Developers Spending Millions On Sales Galleries

Slate, Hudson Cos. Picked To Develop Massive Queens Housing Project

BXP's 343 Madison Lands $1.2B Loan, Nears Deal With Equity Partner

Ryan Cos. Secures Permit For Austin's Sixth Street Redevelopment

Rapper Rick Ross Joins 670-Unit Miami Gardens Condo Project

Mamdani Adds Millions To Program Helping Retailers Negotiate With Landlords