NYC Comptroller Files $40M Suit Against Developer For Construction Wage Violations

BLDG's multifamily rental property at 212 E. 44th St., known as The Summit, was under construction between 2015 and 2019.
Bldg's Multifamily Rental Property At 212 E. 44Th St., Known As The Summit, Was Under Construction Between 2015 And 2019.

Developer and landlord BLDG Management underpaid construction workers by tens of millions of dollars, according to a new lawsuit filed by New York City Comptroller Brad Lander.

Lander’s office is seeking a total of $40M from BLDG, according to the suit filed fith the NYC Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings.

Lander's office is asking for $8M in penalties, in addition to $32M that it alleges the developer should have paid workers at its apartment project at 212 E. 44th St.

BLDG completed construction in 2019 on the 429-unit rental building known as The Summit, a block East of the Chrysler Building. The property reaches 42 stories high and reserved roughly 20% of its units as income-restricted under the 421-a tax abatement, Commercial Observer reported.

The 421-a tax break also requires construction workers to be paid a minimum average wage of around $60 per hour. But when the comptroller’s Bureau of Labor Law inspected BLDG’s payroll records in May 2022, a standard process for developers and owners hoping to receive the 421-a tax break, it claims it found that the average hourly wage paid to workers was $31.88 an hour.

“As part of receiving an as-of-right tax benefit, developers must pay the minimum average hourly wage to their construction workers — or face penalties,” Claudia Henriquez, Bureau of Labor Law director of workers’ rights, said in a statement. “If you want to build under 421-a, then adhering to its labor rules is non-negotiable. Our office will continue to ensure developers prioritize fair labor practices.”

BLDG didn't immediately respond to Bisnow’s request for comment.

BLDG’s East 44th Street project has received tax exemptions amounting to $23.1M to date, the comptroller’s suit says. The building’s 35-year tax break is due to expire in 2054.

Under the 2017 version of 421-a, developers working on properties with 300 or more residential units have to guarantee the minimum average hourly wage of $60 in Manhattan and appoint an independent monitor to certify the payroll report submitted to the city.

“Every New Yorker deserves a fair wage and an equitable work environment, especially those that lay the foundation for affordable housing across NYC,” NYC Housing Preservation and Development Commissioner Adolfo Carrión Jr. said in a statement. “HPD believes in accountability and agrees with the Comptroller that adhering to the 421-a program’s labor rules is non-negotiable.”

Continue reading this story with a free account

Log in or register
Sign up for more articles like this
Subscribe to Bisnow's New York Newsletters
Related Stories

Scale Without Blind Spots: Why National Contractors Must Lead Locally

Years Later, Millions In Chicago Housing Projects Remain Unbuilt

NYC Is Building Hotels Again. It May Not Be Enough

Developers Scheme To Build More Housing Units As NYC's Tax Incentive Ages

Interest Rate Hike Douses Outlook For Atlanta Developers

Tishman Speyer Retakes Chrysler Building, Plans $235M Renovation

Why Hospitals Must Be Designed For Talent Retention

Activist Investor Buys Stake In Empire State Building Owner

DRA Buys Stake In 1301 Sixth Ave. At $1.3B Valuation: The N.Y. Deal Sheet

Brookfield Teams Up With Developer For UK Affordable Housing Push

Major NYC Multifamily Firm Expands With Tech-Driven Operations

Hedge Fund Breaks NYC Record With $375-Per-SF Office Lease