The Supreme Court's Worst Decision (According to Justice Stevens)

At 94 years old, retired Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens is still going strong. He recently spoke to students at Georgetown Law School about the Court's low point.

Bush v. Gore was the worst decision while he was on the court (1975 to 2010), said Stevens, here with G'town Law Dean William Treanor. Citizens United was bad enough, but Bush v. Gore was worse: it gave the public the "incorrect impression that the court is a political body." Justice Stevens published a book this year called Six Amendments. His proposed changes to the Constitution include overturning the Second Amendment and getting rid of the death penalty. The most important of the six, though, is dealing with gerrymandering, he says, with campaign finance a close second.

Before he was nominated to SCOTUS, Justice Stevens says he was invited to a dinner at the White House with President Ford and the sitting Justices—and 25-30 other judges. He and a longtime friend and possible nominee, Judge Philip Tone, agreed to tell each other anything they heard. The Friday after Thanksgiving, he recalls, Ford called him up and said that he'd like to nominate him later that day, and to keep it a secret. Stevens replied that he'd promised to tell Tone...and later that day, someone from the White House called Stevens back and said he could tell his friend shortly in advance of the official announcement. Justice Stevens' advice to students is to "realize when you start practicing law, that your most important asset is your reputation for integrity."

Continue reading this story with a free account

Log in or register
Sign up for more articles like this
Subscribe to Bisnow's Washington, D.C. Newsletters
Related Stories

Fairfax Developers Struggle To Build Enough To Fill Affordable Housing Gaps

Prince William County Drastically Shrinks By Right Data Center Map

Developer Pays $7M For Planned Old Town Conversion: The D.C. Deal Sheet

Ruben Cos. Says It Can't Sell, Finance Navy Yard Multifamily Project

D.C. Court Tosses Lawsuit Over Proposed Rent-Freeze Ballot Initiative

Loudoun County Moves To Pause Data Center Applications For 12 Months

Why Top-Secret Facilities Are Permeating Greater D.C.'s Office Market

Trump's DEI Crackdown Is Creating New Risks For Landlords That Lease To The Government

Northern Virginia Office Tower Sells For Double Its 2024 Price

Design Plans Revealed For RFK Stadium Parking Garages, Headed To Review

Security Tech Firm Plans Loudoun HQ Move: The D.C. Deal Sheet

D.C. Investor Behind The Stacks Swaps CEO For First Time In 25 Years